long ago ideas

“When we are tired, we are attacked by ideas we conquered long ago." - Friedrich Nietzsche. Long ago, Joseph Smith and Oliver Cowdery conquered false claims that the Book of Mormon was fiction or that it came through a stone in a hat. But these old claims have resurfaced in recent years. To conquer them again, we have to return to what Joseph and Oliver taught.

Friday, January 31, 2025

Podcast-MBR on Joseph Smith, etc.

Mormon Book Reviews released a new podcast yesterday titled "New Approaches to Joseph Smith." You should definitely watch it.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6u9-6k0k0Y4

In my view, it makes a big difference to see how God prepared Joseph Smith from his youth for his future role as translator and prophet, instead of the narrative that Joseph was an ignorant farm boy who said a prayer out loud.

As we've discussed before, Joseph himself said the Restoration started when he was a young boy. His brush with death through his leg surgery and recovery made him a religious seeker, as he explained in his 1832 history.

For additional material, see 

https://www.ldshistoricalnarratives.com/2024/09/joseph-smith-early-years.html

and

https://www.ldshistoricalnarratives.com/2024/09/the-embarrassed-narrative-and-sith.html

From Joseph's experience, we each learn that our own spiritual development and relationship with God is directly linked to our desires and the effort we employ to seek God. Which is what the scriptures have said all along.

This is also important for understanding Joseph as a translator, as he and Oliver said. IOW, he didn't merely read words that appeared on the stone-in-the-hat (SITH), but he actually translated the engravings on the plates, as the Lord instructed him, using the Urim and Thummim that came with the plates (D&C 10:41).

_____

Related to this, I uploaded another annotation of a chapter in the Book of Mormon, in this case Alma 12.

https://www.mobom.org/bm-kjv-and-je-alma-12

and here:

https://dailyjonathanedwards.blogspot.com/2025/01/alma-12-annotated.html

If you'd like the Word version, which is easier to follow because the footnotes are at the end of each page, just email me at lostzarahemla@gmail.com and I'll email it to you.

You can see all the annotated chapters here:

https://www.mobom.org/jonathan-edwards

It's cool to see how Joseph employed his own vocabulary and knowledge to translate the plates "after the manner of his language."

Plus, seeing the connections with Jonathan Edwards expands the text considerably, just like seeing the connections with the Bible does.


Thursday, January 30, 2025

Updated "Simplicity" post

By far the most popular post on this blog over the years has been the one titled "Simplicity."

I recently updated it. 

You can see it here:

https://www.bookofmormoncentralamerica.com/2016/05/simplicity.html

Feel free to share it widely.

Or better, share this link to the Scripture Central Peer Reviews:

https://scripturecentralpeerreviews.blogspot.com/2025/01/simplicity-two-sets-of-assumptions.html

_____

When we compare the two sets of assumptions, we're reminded of this wisdom from Naval Ravikant.

"It is the mark of a charlatan to explain a simple concept in a complex way" - @naval


Follow the money-Scripture Central, M2C and SITH

M2C and SITH continue to be cited as among the top reasons why people lose their faith in the Restoration. This is obvious when leading LDS scholars teach that Joseph and Oliver deliberately misled everyone about the origin and setting of the Book of Mormon. 

Few if any people join the Church and remain active because of the theories of scholars, but when the scholars repudiate the teachings of the prophets, they cause people to question their faith. 

People often ask how and why so many LDS scholars and their followers continue to promote M2C and SITH. 

It's an easy answer: just follow the money. 

It's basically the same reason why Americans spend more on health care than any other country, with the worst medical outcomes of any developed country, as we'll see below. The solution for the health care outcomes is relatively easy, except that the solution impinges on big corporate interests who fund the politicians.

Likewise, the tragedy is that Scripture Central could easily solve this problem by simply 

(i) acknowledging the teachings of the prophets and 

(ii) acknowledging the evidence that corroborates those teachings and

(iii) encouraging Latter-day Saints and their friends to make informed decisions.

But so far, Scripture Central continues to refuse to do these three things.

_____

Scripture Central raises and spends millions of dollars annually. No other LDS academic organization comes close.

To participate with Scripture Central as management, as an employee, as a volunteer, as a content creator, or in any other way, you must comply with the Scripture Central's position on the origin and setting of the Book of Mormon. 

This means you must agree to repudiate the teachings of the prophets about the origin and setting of the Book of Mormon; i.e., you must believe, or at least promote, 

(i) the Mesoamerican/two-Cumorahs theory (M2C) of the setting of the Book of Mormon, and 

(ii) the stone-in-the-hat (SITH) explanation for the origin of the Book of Mormon.

In fact, to participate with Scripture Central, you can't even teach what the prophets have taught about the origin and setting of the Book of Mormon because both M2C and SITH expressly and explicitly repudiate the teachings of the prophets about Cumorah/Ramah and the Urim and Thummim. 

We've documented numerous examples of this from Tyler Griffin and others, but in coming days we'll document even more.

Because Scripture Central controls the money, if you want to be an LDS scholar in the present world, you have to comply with--and promote--SITH and M2C.

Scripture Central hosts and coordinates and promotes specific social media influencers, on the condition that they in turn promote M2C and SITH.

Scripture Central funds independent researchers, on the condition that they in turn promote M2C and SITH.

Although much of their content is published anonymously, this list of their "content creators" consists exclusively of people who promote M2C and SITH.

(click to enlarge)

Think about this: for all of 2024, when Come Follow Me focused on the Book of Mormon, these "content creators" generated numerous articles, podcasts, videos, and other content, but not one of them ever once quoted what Joseph Smith and Oliver Cowdery taught about the origin and setting of the Book of Mormon.

Instead, they promoted their own theories and quoted and cited one another. It's amazing, but not surprising if you follow the money.

(In case I missed an example, let me know so I can correct this post. Email me at lostzarahemla@gmail.com).

_____

Now, here's the analogy to the US health care system:

RFK Jr. explaining the US health care system

Camus
@newstart_2024
Robert F. Kennedy Jr.: "Today, over 100 members of Congress support a bill to fund Ozempic with Medicare at $1,500 a month. Most of these members have taken money from the manufacturer of that product, a European company called Novo Nordisk. As everyone knows, once a drug is approved for Medicare, it goes to Medicaid." "And there is a push to recommend Ozempic for Americans as young as six over a condition, obesity, that is completely preventable and barely even existed 100 years ago. Since 74% of Americans are obese, the cost of all of them, if they take their Ozempic prescriptions, will be $3 trillion a year. This is a drug that has made Novo Nordisk the biggest company in Europe." "It's a Danish company, but the Danish government does not recommend it. It recommends a change in diet to treat obesity and exercise. Virtually Novo Nordisk's entire value is based upon its projections of what Ozempic is going to sell to Americans. For half the price of Ozempic, we could purchase regeneratively raised organic agriculture, organic food for every American three meals a day and gym membership for every obese American." "Why are members of Congress doing the bidding of this Danish company instead of standing up for American farmers and children? Because Novo Nordisk is one of the largest funders of medical research, the media and politicians and the medical schools all go along with them."

Monday, January 27, 2025

The narrow neck of land found!

Yesterday I visited an actual narrow neck of land that connects a land northward and a land southward that are surrounded by water in an island of the sea.

Looking southward:

(click to enlarge)

A wide-angle shot shows how narrow the neck is. It could be described as a narrow neck, a narrow passage, or even a small neck of land.


Looking northward, the neck expands into a large island.


On the map it's easy to see the land northward and southward connected by the narrow neck.


To get to Bruny Island we took a ferry from Kettering, Tasmania.

Obviously I don't think this is the land of the Book of Mormon, but it makes the point that once people reject the teachings of the prophets, the way the management and scholars at Scripture Central do, there is no principled limit on the possible settings of the Book of Mormon.

There are hundreds, if not thousands, of locations around the world that could fit the description in the Book of Mormon.

That's why it is essential for Latter-day Saints to start by accepting the teachings of the prophets about the New York Cumorah/Ramah. Even when we have the Cumorah pin in the map, there are numerous plausible scenarios, but at least they corroborate the teachings of the prophets.

Bruny Island, south of Hobart






Friday, January 24, 2025

Scripture Central Peer Reviews

There is so much misinformation and disinformation pouring out of Scripture Central lately that we're starting a new blog to provide peer reviews of their content.

https://scripturecentralpeerreviews.blogspot.com/

Here's the first entry.

https://scripturecentralpeerreviews.blogspot.com/2025/01/kno-why-489-where-is-hill-cumorah.html

We'll have peer reviews of the Kno-Why articles, youtube and other videos, and other content.

Feel free to share widely!

Wednesday, January 15, 2025

Thank you Brant Gardner, again


I posted a peer review of Brant's latest two books. Overall I thought they were well done and useful, but in some respects manipulative and misleading because of Brant's M2C convictions.

https://interpreterpeerreviews.blogspot.com/2025/01/peer-review-of-brant-gardners-latest.html

Brant explains but does not resolve the obvious problem that the Title Page was on the last leaf of the plates. This means there were no additional plates (such as the plates of Nephi, commonly referred to as the "small plates." 

This means that Joseph obtained the "small plates" separately from the abridged plates that Moroni put in the stone box, as anyone can see from D&C 9 and 10. David Whitmer reported that he encountered the messenger who had the abridged plates. This was when he he was with Joseph and Oliver, traveling from Harmony to Fayette. He offered the messenger a ride, but the messenger declined, saying he was "going to Cumorah."

This used to be a well-known account in the Church. It was in my seminar manual. But the M2Cers have managed to "de-correlate" that account because it is solid evidence that Cumorah/Ramah, including the repository of Nephite records, is in New York. 

One solution Brant proposes is that Joseph didn't even know he was translating the small plates!

Here's an excerpt from my peer reviews (Brant's original in blue, my comments in red).

"it may not have been until Joseph was translating 1 Nephi 9 that he realized that he was now translating a completely separate record from the one Mormon had based his history on."

This speculation by Brant ignores the between D&C 9 and 10. It assumes that Joseph wasn’t really reading from the plates, contrary to Brant’s explanation of the translation. If Joseph didn’t know he was translating “the plates of Nephi” instead of the abridgment by Mormon/Moroni, then how did he know whether he was obeying the Lord’s instructions? For that matter, why would the Lord specify what plates he should translate? And why would Joseph and Oliver even think of re-translating the book of Lehi if they still had a stack of untranslated plates after the Book of Moroni and the Title Page?

That Brant ignores these questions may be explained by his omission of David Whitmer’s explanation that the messenger who took the abridged plates from Joseph in Harmony declined David’s offer of a ride to Fayette because he was “going to Cumorah.”

(For trip to Fayette references, see https://www.mobom.org/trip-to-fayette-references)

Obviously, the Cumorah problem looms large in this narrative.

It continues to amaze us how the M2Cers completely ignore the evidence of the New York Cumorah/Ramah. To Brant's credit, he merely omitted the evidence. 

Jack Welch not only omitted the evidence, but he falsified the account in his infamous Opening the Heavens entry.

https://www.bookofmormoncentralamerica.com/2017/12/opening-heavens-but-censoring-history.html 

I continually hope that Scripture Central will, at some point, be open and transparent about all of this. So far, they've shown zero interest in helping people make informed decisions.